Dock Building Comparisons

Every comparison on this hub is written by Mark Lipe from 30+ years of installing and tearing out both sides of the decision. We build floating docks AND fixed piers. We install IPE AND pressure-treated decking. We replace dock components AND we tell homeowners when their dock is past saving. We make money either way — which means the verdict in each comparison reflects what actually lasts on coastal NC waterfronts, not which option earns us a bigger ticket.

If you are starting a new build, decide floating dock vs fixed pier first — it drives every other spec. If you already have a damaged dock, start with repair vs replace. Decking material (IPE vs PT) is a finish-level decision you can make after structural choices are settled.

Yes. Every number — lifespan, cost, failure mode, salt corrosion timing — reflects what we have seen on Pender, New Hanover, and Onslow County waterfronts. A floating dock vs fixed pier decision in fresh-water Tennessee is a different conversation. The 3–4 ft tide swing on the Intracoastal Waterway, the chloride-rich salt environment, and the Wind Zone D hurricane exposure all shape these comparisons.

It usually is. Real waterfronts rarely fall cleanly on one side of a decision. The "Who each is for" section of every comparison lists the specific conditions where each option wins — water depth, tide swing, intended use, budget. If you read a comparison and still are not sure, call us. We have walked enough bulkheads to recognize edge cases.

Yes. Our service catalog covers both sides of every comparison on this hub: floating docks AND fixed piers, IPE AND pressure-treated decking, repair AND replacement, 316 stainless AND galvanized (where appropriate). We will not upsell you into the more expensive option unless your bulkhead actually requires it.